Friday, November 2, 2012

Yahweh Goes to Washington

This is an editorial written for my Advanced Writing class.
Warning: Divisive opinion ahead.

Senate candidate Richard Mourdock:
Male expert on women's rights.

          Indiana’s Republican Senate candidate Richard Mourdock stunned and disgusted many when he stated that pregnancies resulting from rape are “something that God intended to happen.” Now one could argue over the theological inferences that statement leads to (namely, God intends for rape to happen), but I ask instead: why does it matter? Thomas Jefferson believed religion to be a personal matter that must necessarily be separated from the affairs of the state. In a now famous letter written to the Danbury Baptist Association, Jefferson stated there must be a “wall of separation between church and state.” So how is it that government officials come to speak so openly and vigorously about God (and it is always God) in debates?

The wall Jefferson spoke of is no iron curtain; it could now be likened to an old bedsheet – flimsy, easily twisted, and even more easily cast aside. As the election looms this bedsheet is being battered from both sides. The Roman Catholic Church is on one side and members of congress on the other. In a coincidence as stunning as Mourdock’s rape comments, both sides are fighting over God’s place in women’s health care.
The Church sees President Obama’s new employee health insurance regulations as blatant attack on their constitutional rights. Chief amongst their complaints is the requirement to provide women the option of birth control, so called “morning after” pills, and sterilization. Failure to comply (though the President has extended the deadline) will result in fines levied against the organization. Church officials are calling this a violation of their religious liberties and their religious conscience. They disagree that hiring employees outside of the church should subject them to the laws governing those people and they most stringently disagree with contraception legislature. This reveals a rather gaping disconnect between the church and its flock because these employees aren’t just heathen non-believers seeking a way to avoid the consequences of their carnal desires. 98% of sexually active Catholic women in the United States use birth control. And President Obama’s regulations in no way force Catholic organization employees to use contraception, only that the option and access be provided.
Opposition on the other side of the bedsheet is lead primarily by GOP congressman whose war on women’s health care has waged long and hard. Abortions are an abomination, they say. Life is a gift from God, they say. Life begins at conception, they say. You must all be subject to our religious interpretation of birth, they don’t say, but it is what they mean. And it shouldn’t matter. Rick Santorum has said the separation of church and state disgusts him. Presidential candidate Mitt Romney thinks the separation of church and state has been taken “well beyond its original meaning.” Both fail to see that Jefferson’s wall is practically nonexistent.
I am reminded of my time in high school and the debate sparked by my US Government teacher. “What do we think about the thought for the day?” He asked us. The thought for the day broadcast every morning over the school speakers was invariably a quote from scripture. My high school was (and still is) a public institution. I raised my hand and said I believed it to be a violation of the First Amendment. A girl behind me raised her hand and told me if I didn't like it then I didn't have to listen to it.
Does the same apply when it’s the law?

No comments:

Post a Comment